Skip to main content
1031Property.com — 1031 exchange & DST replacement property specialists
1031 Basics

What If the Buyer and Seller Both Do a 1031 Exchange?

6 min read

By 1031Property Research TeamLast updated

Researched against current IRS guidance and reviewed before publication. Educational information only — not tax, legal, or investment advice. See our disclosures.

It works, and it happens often. When the buyer and the seller of the same property are both doing a 1031 exchange, there are simply two separate exchanges that meet at one closing. The seller is completing the relinquished side of their exchange, the buyer is completing the replacement side of theirs, and each has its own Qualified Intermediary, its own exchange agreement and its own 45 and 180 day clocks. Neither exchange depends on the other succeeding for tax purposes, but the two timelines can pull against each other, so the contract and the closing need to be planned with both in mind.

This article is educational only. It is not tax, legal or investment advice. Every exchange should be reviewed with your CPA, a real estate attorney and your Qualified Intermediary.

Is this the same as swapping properties?

No. A direct swap, where two owners trade properties with each other, is a different arrangement and is far less common. In the situation covered here, money changes hands in the usual way. The buyer's intermediary sends exchange funds to the closing, the seller's intermediary receives the sale proceeds, and the property is deeded directly from the seller to the buyer.

Each owner is in a different stage of their own exchange. For the seller, this sale is usually day zero, the event that starts both of their clocks. For the buyer, this purchase is often the end of an exchange that started weeks or months earlier when they sold something else.

Does each side need its own Qualified Intermediary?

In practice, yes. Each exchange has its own agreement, its own accounting and its own funds. The intermediary for one side is acting for that taxpayer, not the other.

Occasionally both parties happen to use the same intermediary company. That can make paperwork smoother, but it does not merge the exchanges. They remain two files, two sets of funds and two sets of deadlines. Each party should still confirm that the intermediary is not a disqualified person for them, such as their own agent, attorney or accountant who has acted for them recently.

What goes in the purchase contract?

Both sides should have a cooperation clause. The usual language says that each party intends to complete a 1031 exchange, that each will cooperate with the other's exchange, that each may assign its rights under the contract to its Qualified Intermediary, and that neither will bear extra cost or liability because of the other's exchange.

Because both parties are exchanging, the clause works in both directions. The seller needs to assign the sale side to their intermediary, and the buyer needs to assign the purchase side to theirs. Both assignments are normally signed before or at closing, with written notice to the other party. Your intermediary will supply the documents, and your attorney should review the contract language before signing.

Whose deadline drives the closing?

Usually the buyer's, and this is where most of the tension comes from.

The buyer may be well into their own 180 day period, perhaps with only a few weeks left. They have already identified this property, so they cannot easily walk away and find another. The seller, on the other hand, is just starting their clock and wants enough runway to find a replacement of their own.

Consider an illustrative example. These figures are illustrative only and are not a projection or a recommendation.

  • ›The buyer sold a property 130 days ago and identified this building as one of their replacements. They have 50 days left to close.
  • ›The seller has not yet found a replacement. The day they close this sale, their own 45 day identification period begins.

If the seller delays closing to give themselves more time to shop, the buyer's exchange is put at risk. If the seller closes quickly to help the buyer, the seller's own 45 days begin before they are ready. Neither owner can borrow time from the other. The practical answer is to agree a closing date early that both sides can live with and write it into the contract with realistic contingencies.

Can one exchange fail without the other?

Yes. The two exchanges are independent for tax purposes. If the buyer fails to complete their exchange for an unrelated reason, perhaps a different identified property falls through, the seller's sale is still a valid start to the seller's exchange. If the seller later fails to identify replacement property, that does not reach back and affect the buyer's purchase.

What they share is the closing itself. If this closing does not happen, both are affected at once. The seller has no proceeds to exchange, and the buyer may have lost one of their identified properties.

What about the settlement statement?

There will usually be one closing with entries for both parties, or separate buyer and seller statements. Each owner should have their own CPA or intermediary review their own side.

The seller is watching for anything paid from proceeds that could create boot, such as prorated rent, security deposits handed to the buyer, or cash paid out at closing. The buyer is watching for the opposite risk: whether the exchange funds sent by their intermediary are applied only to the purchase price and qualifying closing costs, and whether their new loan replaces the debt they paid off on their earlier sale. Credits that move between the two parties affect both sides' numbers, so a credit negotiated late in the deal deserves a second look from both.

Yes, and this is the one situation where the two exchanges can become tangled. Sales between related parties, such as family members or entities under common control, are subject to special rules under Section 1031(f), including a two year holding requirement and limits on buying replacement property from a related party. If there is any family or ownership connection between the buyer and seller, raise it with both CPAs before the contract is signed.

A short checklist for a two sided exchange

  • ›Confirm early that both parties intend to exchange and say so in the contract.
  • ›Make sure each side has engaged its own Qualified Intermediary before closing.
  • ›Agree a closing date that respects the buyer's remaining days and the seller's planning needs.
  • ›Have both assignment notices signed and delivered before closing.
  • ›Ask each intermediary how much notice it needs to wire funds or receive them.
  • ›Review the settlement statement separately for each side, looking for boot.
  • ›Disclose any family or ownership relationship between the parties.

The bottom line

When both parties are exchanging, the tax mechanics are no harder than in any other exchange. What gets harder is coordination. Two intermediaries, two calendars and two sets of advisers all have to land on the same closing day. Owners who discuss the plan openly at the contract stage tend to find the process routine. Those who discover the other side's deadline at the last minute are the ones who end up negotiating under pressure.

Ready to see real options?

Get illustrative DST, net-lease, and fund options matched to your situation — free, no obligation.

This article is educational and not tax, legal, or investment advice. 1031 exchanges are complex — consult your own CPA and attorney. DST and fund offerings are securities available to accredited investors only; all examples are illustrative.