Somewhere between accepting an offer and closing, you will hand your entire sale proceeds to a company you probably found last week. They will hold that money for up to 180 days. In most states nobody licenses them, examines their books or insures what they are holding.
That is the Qualified Intermediary arrangement, and it is not optional. What is optional is how carefully you choose one.
Why do you need a Qualified Intermediary?
Because a 1031 exchange fails the moment you have access to your own money.
The rule is constructive receipt. If the proceeds from your sale touch your hands, your bank account or an account you control, even for an afternoon, the exchange is over and the sale is fully taxable. A Qualified Intermediary exists to stand between you and the money so that constructive receipt never happens.
They receive the proceeds at closing, hold them, and release them to buy your replacement property. They also prepare the exchange agreement and assignment documents that make the transaction a legal exchange rather than a sale followed by a purchase.
When does this decision have to be made?
Before your relinquished property closes. Not on the day. Not afterwards.
The exchange agreement must be signed and the intermediary assigned into the contract before the sale completes. Close first and there is no retrofit available. This is the single most common way a 1031 exchange fails, and it fails completely rather than partially.
Practically, that means engaging an intermediary as soon as you have a buyer, and ideally before.
Are Qualified Intermediaries regulated?
Not at federal level, and only lightly in a handful of states. There is no national licensing regime, no capital requirement and no examination in most of the country.
A few states, including Nevada, California, Virginia and Washington, impose some obligations such as bonding or minimum insurance. Most impose nothing at all. The qualification in Qualified Intermediary refers to their disqualification rules under the tax code, meaning they must not be your agent, attorney or accountant within the last two years. It is not a competence standard.
This is not theoretical. Intermediaries have failed, and investors have lost entire exchange deposits. The ones who came through it best were generally the ones who had insisted on the protections below.
What should you ask before you sign?
How are my funds held? The answer you want is a segregated, separate account in your name or clearly identified to your exchange. The answer you do not want is a commingled pooled account where your money sits alongside everyone else's. Commingling is legal, common and the thing that turns one failure into many.
What is your fidelity bond and errors and omissions cover? Ask for the amounts and ask for evidence. Then ask whether the bond covers your specific transaction or is an aggregate across all clients, which is a very different thing when several exchanges fail at once.
Who can authorise a withdrawal? Dual authorisation, requiring your written instruction, is a meaningful protection. Sole authorisation by the intermediary is not.
Who earns the interest? A small point financially and a revealing one. The answer should be disclosed without hesitation either way.
How long have you been doing this, and how many exchanges a year? Volume and longevity both matter. A firm that has processed thousands of exchanges has seen the edge cases that will otherwise surprise you on day 44.
Are you a member of the Federation of Exchange Accommodators? Membership is not a guarantee, but it indicates a firm operating to a published code rather than outside any framework at all.
Who actually handles my file? You want a named person who answers the phone during your identification window, not a general inbox.
What should make you walk away?
- ›Reluctance to confirm segregated accounts in writing
- ›Vagueness about bonding or insurance amounts
- ›Fees quoted without a written schedule
- ›A firm that also wants to sell you the replacement property, which creates an obvious conflict and can raise disqualification questions
- ›Any suggestion that you can close first and sort out the exchange afterwards, which is simply wrong and tells you everything
Is the cheapest intermediary a false economy?
Usually. Fees typically run from several hundred to a couple of thousand dollars for a standard delayed exchange.
Against a tax bill that can exceed 300,000 dollars on an appreciated property, the difference between the cheapest and the most careful intermediary is rounding error. Choosing on price is optimising the smallest number in the transaction while ignoring the largest.
What to do this week
If a sale is anywhere on your horizon, choose an intermediary before you have a buyer. The conversation is calmer, the diligence is real rather than rushed, and you remove the most common single point of failure in the entire process.
Ask your CPA and your real estate attorney who they have worked with and, more usefully, who they have stopped working with.
Nothing here is tax, legal or investment advice, and 1031Property is not a Qualified Intermediary and does not hold client funds. Requirements vary by state and change over time. Confirm your own position with your CPA and attorney before you act.
Ready to see real options?
Get illustrative DST, net-lease, and fund options matched to your situation — free, no obligation.
This article is educational and not tax, legal, or investment advice. 1031 exchanges are complex — consult your own CPA and attorney. DST and fund offerings are securities available to accredited investors only; all examples are illustrative.