- Why is the gain so much larger than the last price increase?
- How is the gain calculated on the final sale?
- Which parts of the gain are taxed differently?
- Does anything get released in your favor on a full sale?
- What paperwork changes on the final sale?
- What do owners consider before selling for cash?
- What should you do before signing a listing agreement?
When you sell a property you acquired in a 1031 exchange and do not exchange again, the sale is fully taxable. The gain you deferred in every earlier exchange comes due in that year, together with the gain on the current property and all of the depreciation you took along the way. A 1031 exchange postpones tax. It does not erase it, and the final cash sale is where the postponed amount is settled.
Why is the gain so much larger than the last price increase?
Because your basis did not reset when you exchanged. In a 1031 exchange, the tax basis of the property you sold carries over into the property you bought, adjusted for any cash added or boot received. The deferred gain sits inside that low carried over basis, waiting.
So when you finally sell, the gain is not measured from what you paid for the current property. It is measured from a basis that may trace back to a purchase made decades ago, reduced by every year of depreciation claimed on every property in the chain.
How is the gain calculated on the final sale?
The arithmetic is the same as any sale, but the inputs reach further back.
- ›Amount realized is the sale price minus selling costs such as commissions and closing fees.
- ›Adjusted basis is the carried over basis from your exchanges, plus improvements and any additional cash invested, minus all depreciation taken.
- ›Gain is the amount realized minus the adjusted basis.
The figures below are an illustrative example only, simplified to show the mechanics. They are not a projection and your numbers will differ.
- ›An owner buys a rental for $300,000 and claims $100,000 of depreciation over the years. Adjusted basis is $200,000.
- ›The owner sells it for $700,000 and exchanges the full amount into a $700,000 replacement property. The $500,000 gain is deferred, and the replacement property starts with a $200,000 basis, not $700,000.
- ›Over the following years the owner claims another $120,000 of depreciation on the replacement property. Adjusted basis falls to $80,000.
- ›The owner then sells the replacement property for $900,000 with $50,000 of selling costs, so the amount realized is $850,000.
- ›Taxable gain is $850,000 minus $80,000, which is $770,000.
That $770,000 is the $500,000 deferred from the first exchange plus $270,000 of new gain on the second property, which is $150,000 of net price increase plus $120,000 of depreciation. The owner saw a $200,000 price increase on paper during the second hold. The tax return sees $770,000.
Which parts of the gain are taxed differently?
The total gain is split into layers, and each layer can carry a different federal rate. Your CPA does this split on the return.
- ›Unrecaptured Section 1250 gain. Depreciation claimed on buildings across the whole chain is generally taxed at a federal rate of up to 25 percent. In the illustrative example, assuming all depreciation was on buildings, that is $220,000, the $100,000 from the first property plus the $120,000 from the second.
- ›Section 1245 recapture. If a cost segregation study reclassified parts of a property as personal property, such as appliances, carpet or site improvements, depreciation on those components is generally recaptured as ordinary income.
- ›Long term capital gain. What remains, $550,000 in the example, is generally taxed at the long term capital gains rates of 0, 15 or 20 percent depending on income.
- ›Net investment income tax. A further 3.8 percent can apply to investment gains above certain income thresholds.
- ›State income tax. Most states tax the gain as well. A few states, California among them, track gain deferred on property that was originally located there and expect to collect when the replacement property is eventually sold, even if you now live elsewhere.
A large one time gain can also affect other items, such as Medicare premium surcharges two years later, because those are based on income from two years earlier.
Does anything get released in your favor on a full sale?
Sometimes. If you have suspended passive losses from the property, such as rental losses you could not deduct in earlier years, a fully taxable sale to an unrelated buyer generally frees them to offset income in the year of sale. A 1031 exchange keeps those losses suspended. A cash sale is often the moment they finally become usable.
What paperwork changes on the final sale?
The exchange itself was reported on Form 8824. A fully taxable sale of business or rental property is generally reported on Form 4797, with the gain carried to Schedule D. Your CPA will need the full history: the original purchase price, every exchange, the depreciation schedule for each property, and records of improvements. If those records are thin, the final sale is when the gap becomes expensive, because the basis has to be proven.
What do owners consider before selling for cash?
None of these is a recommendation. Each has costs, risks and conditions, and the right fit depends on your circumstances, which is a conversation for your CPA, attorney and Qualified Intermediary.
- ›Another exchange. Some owners continue exchanging, including into passive structures, to keep deferring.
- ›A partial exchange. Reinvesting part of the proceeds and taking the rest as cash, which is taxable to the extent of the boot received.
- ›An installment sale. Spreading recognition of the gain over the years in which payments are received, although depreciation recapture is generally taxed in the year of sale regardless.
- ›Holding until death. Under current law, heirs generally receive a basis stepped up to fair market value at death, which can eliminate the deferred gain for them. Tax law can change.
- ›Timing the sale. Selling in a year with lower other income can change which rate brackets apply.
Delaware Statutory Trust interests, sometimes used for further exchanges, are securities available only to accredited investors through a licensed broker dealer and definitive offering documents. They carry risk, including loss of principal.
What should you do before signing a listing agreement?
Ask your CPA for a pro forma tax estimate based on your actual basis history, before you agree a price or a closing date. The number is often larger than owners expect, and knowing it early leaves room to plan, whether you sell for cash, exchange again or wait.
A 1031 exchange is a timing tool. Every deferred dollar stays on the books until a taxable sale, a step up at death, or another exchange moves it forward again. Knowing where that number stands today is the most useful thing you can bring to the decision.
Ready to see real options?
Get illustrative DST, net-lease, and fund options matched to your situation — free, no obligation.
This article is educational and not tax, legal, or investment advice. 1031 exchanges are complex — consult your own CPA and attorney. DST and fund offerings are securities available to accredited investors only; all examples are illustrative.
